I am 5 months pregnant and we r still confused about good maternity hospital.We have shortlisted manipal and Fortis but we are open for any other good option. Anybody who has experience with these two please suggest which one is better.
Thanks in advance
Hi, A lot depends on the distance of the hospital from your residence. Manipal is no doubt a good hospital. Both my kids are born there. I have heard that Cradle is also a good hospital. It is in Jayanagar.
thakursamy, if you do not mind the cost then there is motherhood hospital in Indiranagar where my sil just delivered her baby. Its just like a 5 star place and my sil was treated like royalty. There were lots of doctors and nurses around her during her labour and my brother was also allowed inside the labour room to be with her(not sure if this is the trend now anyway in the cities). She delivered the baby through normal delivery- normal delivery is now not very common in the cities.
Happy pregnanthood first of all.
I had my delivery in Cradle, it is maternity speciality hospital in Jayanagar. I found doctors are good, approachable & nurses are very caring. They have pre-natal yoga classes, lactation expert & dietacian to help you post delivery. They allow father of the child into the delivery room. But costwise, Cradle is always on the higher side. And yes, you will not feel like that you have stepped into any Hospital.. this i liked most there as I always hate that Hospital smell.
I would suggest you to decide on the hospital depending on two criteria:
First, the distance from your residence. In the last months of pregnancy u need to go for weeky/ bi-weekly check ups. You will be tired to travel long distances for sure.
Second, which doctor you are referring and how much u r comfortable with the doctor. Doctor should be approachable and patient to listen all our worries and concerns.
P.S. I expressed my personal view point about Cradle..
cradle is really good.............my bhabhi got her delivery done thr..services r too good
I had my delivery in Cradle ,3rd block jaynagar.i started the consulting Dr. Prakash Kini at 6th month onwards. he is really good. my friend also followed me with him later ..
The nurses are very caring. They have pre-natal yoga classes, lactation expert & dietacian to help you post delivery.
And yes, i agree too that you will not feel like that you have stepped into any Hospital..
i'm not aware of your location .. but if u have chosen manipal i guess it near to indiranagar or marathalli side.. anyway .. u don't have to worry abt the distance.. its wll hardly take a hr max to reach from that side of the town.. i'm from kalyanagar and my preference initially was manipal.. later my gynae friend had a bad experience with them. she being a doc was little rest assured but advised me not to go in there.
the treatment and staff / service is really pathetic. about the cost .. i had c-section and it cost me 50k .
i was a first time mother and it really made a delivery a joy..
anyway all the best ..
I too consulted Dr. Kini..what i liked about him is that he is very calm, poised & had answers for all my questions!! Being a first time mother is always a spl experience.. & i really enjoyed having my bundle of joy there.
BTW..I had a baby boy..how about urs? When you delivered.. just being inquisitive :)
sorry i don't chk everyday. and i was out of station for a week ..
my "daughter" now is 2.4 years.. (oct 2008 ).till recently we were going to Cradle for her vaccines with Dr. Kishore.
yeah ur correct. he is a splendid doc.. u feel very confortable with him:)
Thanks a lot for your responses.
Hi NJ, thanx fr yr response n sorry am bit late in responding. after all the responses we got and lil bit of survey we've zeroed down to manipal and motherhood. as we stay in whitefield area so both are at equal distance. The problem is that motherhood is not having any reviews on net and though the doctors seem good i am stil confused which one is best amongst them. I'l appreciate if u take some time and let me know which doctor yr SIL consulted and at the time of delivery she was the only doctor present or there were other doctors also.Her delivery was planned or it was an emergency and how good the hospital was in handling this emergency, how was the attitude of nursing staff and admin. the package they give is all they charge or the cost goes very up.........Please please please help me sort out my confusion as i ca't find any other source of info regarding motherhood.
Thanx in advance
is st.philomena hospital good?
I just saw your pm this night. I shall ask my sil tomorrow on your queries and reply back more specifically. My sils gynac is a consultant in vittal mallya hospital. I dont recall her name now and I'm not sure if she recommended this hospital or if my brother found it or if any of my brothers friends recommended it. My brother stays in kasturinagar, so this hospital was also close to him. They were also considering manipal hospital at that time. This hospital was started only about a year or 2 ago and it is malayalam actor mammootys brother in laws hospital. You may not have found reviews on the net because its new while others have been around a while. My sils gyn had told her that if its a normal delivery then the doctors in the hospital would take care of it, but if she needs to have a c section then she should be called. My sils due date was March 20 but she went into labour on Mar 1st and my brother took her to the hospital. The nurses and doctors there attended to her and she delivered her baby in 3 hours. Everything went smoothly for them, there were no complaints. She was discharged in 2 days. I will get the details like the doctors name and hospital expense from her tomorrow.
Good luck on your delivery.
The doctors name is Sushila shetty and the cost for normal comes to around 45 000 all inclusive(food, doctors fee , physiotherapy etc). For normal they usually stay in the hospital for 2 days and if you want to stay additional day its 2500. For cesarean its 90000 all inclusive. And the stay in hospital is 3-4 days.
Thanks a lot NJ i just saw yr replies as i was in hospital and delivered my baby on 21st in motherhood itself and trust me its the best decision we made.
Thanks for yr responses
hi NJ and thakursamy
ur post has been a help for me to know more abt motherhood
i am pregnant and my due is on mar 2012. i'll am in indiranagar....and happen to visit motherhood a mnth back for enquiry.
when i saw their package was confused ........abt what they provide...and whether they try to make delivery normal as far as possible.
but after reading ur conversation feel they provide good service.
NJ i need to confirm whether sushila shetty was the same doc ur sil consulted in vittal mallya?
and when did they started visiting motherhood ...i mean during which month of prgnancy?
please do write back
and thakursamy...which doc did u consult and from which mnth on wards?
thanks in advance :)
I would also like to know about which would be the best and reasonable hospital near Btm, jaynagar....or any of the immediate surrounding areas? I agree about cradle /cloud 9 hospital in jaynagar in being a good hospital but as per reviews by many people around me ive heard they are very expensive.
it would be really nice if someone could be of help in sugeesting as i need to register to a hospital soon and need help in making that decision
Hi NJ and thakursamy....
saw ur replies.. I am planning to visit Motehrhood... heard goodreviews abt them.. can u please let me know the name of the doctor u attended...
I heard abt dr. vijayalakshmi and planning to go ahead with her.. Pls suggest !!!
Hi meharjish,rubK and hp123,
Sorry guys if i'm late in responding. the reason z my son who keeps me busy whole day. I'l try to reply to u all collectively, i went to motherhood in my 9th month and i consulted Dr. vijaylakshmi and she is a very good doc. i had a C-sec and the cost came close to 93k its less for normal delivery i guess close to 50k and my doc was insisting on normal delivery bt we had to opt for c-sec at the last minute due to some complication.
Other details you can chek with hospital if they have revised rates and if you guyz need any more details feel free to mail me.
Bye and gud luck :)
Hi Thakursamy ,
Thanks for the prompt reply from ur busy time. Hope you and your lil one are doing good.. Planning to go ahead with Dr. Vijayalakshmi as I heard many reviews abt her . how is she ? is she friendly ? does she listen to our problems.? planning to go ahead with motherhood from initial days only. .how was the hospital in terms of facility . I mean do they have sufficient arrangements to handle emergency situations ???
Hi hp 123,
I found Dr Vijaylakshmi very friendly she always listens to you very calmly. I thot after getting so much publicity she might ve changed but i was wrong , got a chance to meet her again recently regarding some paper work and found her xactly the same warm person. rest you can decide on your own after visiting motherhood
Regarding the facilities i was satisfied with staff and other stuff can't say bout emergency, i guess its better to ask the doc r the admin.
I am a mother of of two year old. We had decided to go to St johns hospital in koramangala for my daughters delivery.
I was perticularly intrested in not going for a c-section therefore did not opt for a private hospital.
The people in St johns are very frendly and the doctor was also very approachable. The facilities are also comparable to any good private hospital in Bangalore
Though I have no personal experience, I have heard that the doctores at Manipal come up with some excuse for a c-section delivery based on the doctors convenience or perhaps to make money.
All the best in..
hi rohiniGNI would like to know / recommend which doctor (gynec) u consulted at St. Johns? How was she? And did u face any problems such as less attention, less nursing care, etc at d hospital. Coz ive heard that at St. Johns one has to wait for a long time just for an appointment and also after waiting for very long the doctors hardly give u enuf time when u get in. I agree to the fact that St. Johns would be the most reasonable of all and also most of the doctors at private hospitals are into taking a call for C-sections instead of normal deliveries. Ur suggestion would be nice . Thanx
The posts on this page are very useful - thank you so much for sharing ur experiences and details. Can someone please tell me more about Dr.Praveena Shenoy in Manipal - I am planning to go there for my delivery. I stay near Old Airport Road - near Domlur flyover.
The doctor we went to was Doctor Annamma Thomas. We were initially consulting another doctor in St John's hospital but she was very rude and wanted us to consult her privately so we changed to Dr Annamma,
All the people we interacted with there were very friendly and helpful..
Dr Annamma Thomas was recommended by many of my friends and neighbors. Perhaps that's why she has a long queue of patients.
Yes, its true there are very long queues in St john's hospital, especially on Saturdays. But on weekdays its better.
I did not have any complications or health related issues during my pregnancy so did not have to take much of her time. But I have heard that she gives the correct and required medical advice based on the need of the person.
Just to add.. there were four deliveries that happened along with mine at St john's on the day my baby was born.. All were normal deliveries.. So if that is your criteria, along with NOT getting "incorrect money making medical advices" you could opt for St john's..
Hope this help..
thanx rohini ur reply is of real help to me. I will look into this. I too heard of two doctors from St. Johns, one is Dr. Annamma and the other is Dr. Shirley. Yet to decide on the doctor. As you said there were four deliveries going on at the same time, i wanted to know did the doctor herself take your delivery? , since ive heard that since St. Johns is a medical college at times students are allowed to do it too.
Thanx once again
correction ...read last line as money is a second criteria
I agree with you that money is an important factor but in our case we compared costs for all nearby hospitals and they were almost same. we considered manipal, fortis and yashomati hospital and found that c-sec will cost almost same in all of them. You urself can get the delivery package/xpenditure brochure and compare the costs.... Neways bangalore is damn xpensive in everything and its really difficult to find something economical but u can try :)
Thanks Thakursamy for taking time out and replying...
Yes , its true Blore is too expensive from last ~2 yrs or so , any idea how is yashomati hospital?
And is it possible to know names of Dr in Fortis ,Motherhood and Manipal ?
Please please reply to this as i dependent on this forum for guidance.
I heard there is private Dr from Kerla behind Leela Palace she is an old lady and also going to lake view hospital.
Also how is Dr Rita -she is in HSR layout and guess Head of Dept in St Johns hospital ..i heard good name of her , but HSR and St Johns is far from ITPL so looking to have some thing near old airport or CMH
I went to Yashomati hospital only once and i consulted Dr Geetha komar She seemed nice but when we checked the delivery price in Yashomati it was at par with other big hospitals and at that time yashomati was quite new so we dropped the idea. At manipal i used to consult Dr Meena Muthaiah and she is a very good doc but we dropped manipal also as i had to wait in long queues for consultation as well as scans and while pregnant you don't have that much patience and finally we finalized motherhood as the doc i consulted there (dr vijaylakshmi) was very good as well as the services there were nice and queues were short as compared to manipal. Regarding the cost all three were at par so money as a criteria was ruled out and we kept services as a criteria.
Well i have no idea about the other docs u are asking so can't help you.
Recently i noticed cloud9 at old airport road opposite to Total Mall you can chek with them also as i have read a lot about cloud9 bt never had an experience with the hospital as it was far off. Well i'l suggest if u have time go and visit all these and then u can finalize which hospital is good for you as u yrself are a better judge wat suits you.